20
Nov
08

Diving into the past

Originally, I was planning on writing about the Rideau Centre for this post; where it came from, what it replaced and how it impacts the urban landscape today. However, whenever I set out to do something I almost inevitably get sidetracked by something, and while researching this post I ended up coming across a series of aerial photos showcasing the evolution of a particular area of Ottawa. And, if you know anything about me, you know that I was almost instantly fascinated, and I decided I had to craft a post around it.

It all started with this image, taken in 1920:

aerial1920

Photo courtesy Natural Resources Canada, Earth Sciences Sector

Confused and unsure of what it is you’re looking at? Don’t worry, I won’t hold it against you—I know not everyone is as well-versed in analyzing these sorts of things as I am! Here’s a reference version:

aerial1920referenced

Green: City Hall, Teal: Rideau Centre, Red: Conference Centre, Purple: WellingtonRideau St., Yellow: Elgin St., Blue: Laurier Avenue

Make more sense now? The dark section running up the middle, is the Rideau Canal. I find this image really interesting, because it really shows off Ottawa’s roots as an industrial lumber town. In 1920, Ottawa had been Canada’s capital for less than 60 years and it shows. Where the Rideau Centre is today, a large rail yard sprawls just a few hundred metres away from Parliament Hill. Next to it, a quay juts out from the canal, likely a staging ground for passengers and freight to change between the rails and the water.

On the subject of passengers, Union Station dominates a stretch of land next to the canal, a stark contrast to the carefully manicured pathways that exist there now. To the south, a large military staging ground occupies the land where City Hall sits today. If it weren’t for a scattering of prominent landmarks, it’d be impossible to tell this picture is of Ottawa. A lot has changed in the 88 years since it was taken… follow the jump to see some of them.

Before I move on, here’s a better angle of the shot above from roughly the same time period, as far as I can tell.

Image courtesy Natural Resources Canada, Earth Sciences Sector

Image courtesy Natural Resources Canada, Earth Sciences Sector

This shot has a slightly different scope; you can’t see the future site of City Hall, but you can get an idea of the scope of the railway infrastructure, as well as see up into the ByWard Market and into a somewhat less-manicured-looking Major’s Hill Park behind the Chateau Laurier.

And here’s one last photo from this era, this one taken close to the ground:

Image courtesy Canada Science and Technology Museum, Mattingly Collection

To put this into perspective, if you were standing where this photo was taken today, then you’d probably be right next to the National Defence Building, and looking up towards the Congress Centre and Mackenzie King Bridge. I really like this picture since it shows how much space downtown was actually taken up by railway tracks at one point—it’s almost astonishing when you think about how it looks now.

All right, that’s enough of the 1920s. Let’s jump ahead, shall we? How does 1966 sound?

Image courtesy Natural Resources Canada, Earth Sciences Sector

Image courtesy Natural Resources Canada, Earth Sciences Sector

Looks quite a bit different, doesn’t it? The hodgepog of buildings north of the future site of City Hall has vanished, replaced here by efforts to build the National Arts Centre and create Confederation Park in time for Canada’s centennial in 1967. And what of that future City Hall site? Well, it’s taken up by a sprawling complex of “temporary” buildings constructed during the Second World War as office space for military personnel. Meanwhile, tracks still run into Union Station, but not for much longer: 1966 was the year the National Capital Comission decided to take out the railway tracks and replace them with a path system and Colonel By Drive. Finally, Mackenzie King Bridge now stretches across the canal, still 15 years away from being made part of the backbone of Ottawa’s transit system.

Image courtesy Canada Science and Technology Museum, CN Images of Canada Gallery

Image courtesy Canada Science and Technology Museum, CN Images of Canada Gallery

This is another angle from around the same time, though the large rail yard is still intact and Mackenzie King Bridge is only partly complete. You can also see the temporary military office buildings better from this angle, looking somewhat like an attempt to mimic the style of the American military’s Pentagon.

Another jump forwards now, this time to 1973:

Image courtesy Natural Resouces Canada, Earth Sciences Sector

Image courtesy Natural Resouces Canada, Earth Sciences Sector

Now things are looking more like the Ottawa we know today. The squat form of Place Bell can be seen in the lower left corner, and the now-complete National Arts Center sits in the top-left. The temporary military buildings are still in place, but the National Defence Building now sits between Laurier Avenue and Mackenzie King Bridge, meaning they’ll soon be unneeded. Meanwhile, the canal is no longer lined by railway tracks, with Colonel By Drive and landscaped footpaths taking their place. Perhaps the most glaring difference in this image is the large field of parking lots that sit where the Rideau Centre now does. I have to say I’m glad that’s gone; I can only imagine what Rideau Street would be like if there were parking lots there instead of a well-travelled mall and transit stop.

Now then, on to our final jump, to (more or less) the present:

Image courtesy Google Earth

Image courtesy Google Earth

For sticklers, I’m pretty sure this comes from late-2007, so it’s about a year out of date, but I’m not too worried. I won’t describe this in any great detail since I’m sure the landmarks are familiar to most, but I will say that it’s amazing how much more complete it looks with the Rideau Centre in place of those parking lots. Sure it’s a mall, and it probably could have been built to respect the historic buildings that were on the site somewhat better, but all things considered, it’s quite an improvement from the air.

I think, looking at this sequence of images, what’s truly amazing is the fact that this covers maybe a little more than one square kilometre of Ottawa. The changes here are incredibly drastic over a relatively short period of time in the grand scheme of things, and changes like this occured all over the city for periods even longer than this. We tend to think of the places we live as being very permanent, but in reality, they’re extremely fluid. You only need to step back a little bit, and you can see that fluidity in action.

About these ads

12 Responses to “Diving into the past”


  1. November 24, 2008 at 10:35 pm

    Great post, David. Nicely illustrated — I’ve seen a lot of these photos separately but it was interesting to put them in context to see the evolution.

  2. November 24, 2008 at 10:54 pm

    Came here from a plug in the OttawaStart blog. This is a fantastic post, and it’s neat to see how Ottawa has changed, particularly for someone who’s only lived here the last 10 years.

  3. 3 David McClelland
    November 24, 2008 at 11:50 pm

    I’m glad you both liked it. :)

  4. 4 Mike S
    November 25, 2008 at 12:42 am

    I also came from the Ottawastart page. WOW…that is so cool to see how the downtown area has evolved. Too bad the trains no longer head to the city core, that would be a site to see. Thanks for the history info, very interesting….

  5. 5 David McClelland
    November 25, 2008 at 11:56 am

    Glad you enjoyed it!

    Yeah, it’s too bad they couldn’t have kept trains coming into downtown, maybe in a tunnel or something like that. Union Station has always looked like it would be a cool place to catch a train.

  6. November 25, 2008 at 9:22 pm

    Yes, it has. After this year’s Open Doors in particular, I got that particular impression quite thoroughly driven home. We lost out on something, for all the history that’s been made in that building since the changeovers. And it IS History with a capital “H”, to be sure.

  7. December 1, 2008 at 8:38 pm

    Thank you for taking the time to assemble this page. It is very interesting to view these pictures and your commentary in the context of our current issues of public transportation and the new Congress Centre. As a business owner in the Byward Market and board member of the Byward Market BIA, I realize we ALL have a huge responsibility as we shape our city.

  8. 8 David McClelland
    December 1, 2008 at 9:13 pm

    I’m glad you liked the post. And I’m also glad to see that the the owner of a prominent local business recognizes the importance of being involved in shaping the way our city develops.

  9. December 1, 2008 at 9:37 pm

    I remember writing and editing stories at the Fulcrum last year about the future of the university site’s development.

    It turns out much of the land owned by the U of O is part of a big brownfield from the days of yore when, as you point out, a whole bunch of rail yard ran across what is now campus.

  10. December 16, 2008 at 9:30 am

    The second image is very special to me as my grandparents lived in the ByWard and often told me of skating on the canal. They were married in 1922 so the picture is from the time they were courting. I haven’t been to Ottawa myself since the mid 60’s so this was a great tour through the years for me. Thanks!

  11. 11 Brian M.
    December 26, 2008 at 2:46 pm

    Nice job, as I was looking a the photos I can see in my mind the buildings that we have lost in Ottawa. Another project if you want to see changes in Ottawa would be Sparks St. and Bank St from Wellington down. As for the comment about much of Ottawa U being from brownspace, that would be of some interest to the people who lived on Cumberland and College Streets who were “moved” to build it. I lost contact with a lot of folk back then (we did not have instant communication abilites) when their houses/schools business disappeared.

  12. December 26, 2008 at 11:49 pm

    This is an excellent post showing the changing urban landscape. I came to your site from the Centretown blog, run by a friend of mine, where a video link I posted elsewhere inspired this post: http://centretown.blogspot.com/2008/10/video-of-union-railway-pre-colonel-by.html

    The railways defined, aided, and interfered with, Ottawa for a century, and the story is an interesting one. It seems that with the current debate regarding where to put new rails we may be wondering why we gave up some many rail right-of-ways 40-plus years ago (of course those routes gave us the Queensway, Vanier Parkway, Western Parkway and the Transitway alongside Scott St. and also Col. By Drive). If anyone is interested in Ottawa’s rail history (if for no other reason than to see old photos like the above of Ottawa) I highly recommend Colin Churcher’s pages: http://www.railways.incanada.net/

    In particular:

    http://www.railways.incanada.net/circle/findings.htm

    http://www.railways.incanada.net/map/railwaymaps.html


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


What is this?

This is a blog dedicated to exploring and discussing Ottawa, Canada.

Pages

Contact

Email: dmccl033(at)uottawa(dot)ca

RSS feed

Blog Stats

  • 56,106 hits

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: